MKB Juristen drafts custom legal documents
It is best not to cobble together or copy important contracts, terms and conditions, and other legal documents yourself. We help entrepreneurs on a budget with customized legal solutions, clear costs upfront, and practical explanations.
- Custom contracts, terms and conditions, and legal documents
- Budget-friendly and clear about the costs upfront
- Request a free consultation or a no-obligation quote
What is an earn-out arrangement? It is an agreement in a business acquisition whereby part of the purchase price is paid later, depending on the results the company achieves after the acquisition. Instead of paying the full price upon delivery, the buyer and seller agree that a portion will follow if, for example, revenue or profit reaches an agreed level. The earn-out thus bridges a difference in assessment between the parties regarding the value and future of the company. It is a purchase price mechanism, not a separate agreement, that you record in the purchase agreement.
The short answer
- What: a deferred and conditional part of the purchase price in a business acquisition.
- Objective: to bridge a difference in valuation between buyer and seller.
- Basis: agreed performance criteria, for example revenue, profit, or EBITDA over a period.
- Where regulated: in the purchase agreement (SPA), not in a separate agreement.
- Risk: conflict regarding how the criteria are measured and regarding management during the earn-out period.
What is an earn-out arrangement and why do you use one?
In an acquisition, buyer and seller often disagree on the value. The seller believes in the growth of his company and wants to be compensated for it; the buyer does not want to pay for a future that has yet to prove itself. An earn-out arrangement reconciles these positions. A fixed portion of the price is paid upon delivery, and an additional portion follows if the company achieves the agreed-upon results. If the company performs as the seller predicted, he receives the full price. If this does not happen, the buyer pays less.
The earn-out is therefore both a pricing mechanism and a risk allocation. The seller shares the risk that his optimistic estimate will not materialize, and the buyer limits the risk of paying too much. This structure is particularly common in acquisitions where the value depends heavily on future performance, such as in companies with key personnel or a growing customer base.
How does an earn-out work?
An earn-out consists of a number of fixed elements that you specify in the purchase agreement:
- Performance criteria: on which the deferred payment is based, for example revenue, gross profit or EBITDA.
- Period: the term over which measurements are taken, usually one to three years.
- Calculation: the exact formula and the bases, including which valuation rules apply.
- Maximum and minimum: a ceiling and possibly a floor for the retroactive payment.
- Payment date: when and how the earn-out is paid out.
The conflict risk surrounding the earn-out
The earn-out is notorious for the disputes arising from it. The core of the problem is that, after the acquisition, the seller retains little or no control over the company, while their deferred payment depends on the results. The buyer manages the enterprise and makes decisions that influence performance. This leads to debate: did the buyer suppress revenue by postponing investments, allocating costs, or integrating the company into a larger entity?
Many disputes revolve around the measurement of the criteria. What counts as revenue, how are costs allocated, and which valuation bases apply? Unclear or multiple-interpretation criteria are the main cause of earn-out conflicts. Therefore, a precise description of the calculation, with examples and clear bases, is essential.
The buyer's duty of care
During the earn-out period, the buyer has a duty of care. Under Dutch law, the relationship between the parties is governed in part by reasonableness and fairness (Article 6:248 of the Dutch Civil Code). The buyer may not exercise his control in such a way as to knowingly or unnecessarily frustrate the earn-out. If he does, Article 6:23 of the Dutch Civil Code may come into play: if the party with an interest in the absence of a condition prevents its fulfillment, the condition may nevertheless be deemed fulfilled under certain circumstances. A buyer who artificially keeps results low to avoid deferred payment may therefore run into trouble on this basis.
Because the statutory duty of care is formulated in general terms, parties would be wise to make concrete agreements regarding management during the earn-out period. Consider agreements concerning investments, the continuation of customary business operations, the seller's rights to information, and which decisions the buyer may or may not make independently. The more concretely this is laid down, the smaller the risk of conflict.
A practical example: an SME entrepreneur sells his agency and agrees on an earn-out in two years, based on revenue. The buyer integrates the agency into his own organization and shifts clients to other labels. Revenue in the sold entity declines, while the underlying work continues as usual. The seller argues that the buyer has frustrated the earn-out, and the dispute revolves around the question of whether the buyer has breached his duty of care.
Honest recommendation
You do not always need a lawyer. If the full purchase price is paid upon delivery and there is no deferred payment dependent on future results, then earn-out issues do not arise and a clear purchase agreement suffices. As soon as part of the price becomes dependent on performance after the acquisition, legal advice is highly recommended. The determination of the criteria, the calculation, and the duty of care during the earn-out period are where things go wrong, and a well-drafted arrangement prevents disputes lasting for years.
Want to know more? View the earn-out arrangement, read about drafting an earn-out arrangement and about having an earn-out arrangement drafted.
Frequently Asked Questions
An arrangement in a business acquisition whereby part of the purchase price is paid later, depending on the results the company achieves after the acquisition. It is a purchase price mechanism that you stipulate in the purchase agreement.
To bridge a difference in valuation between buyer and seller. The seller believes in future growth, while the buyer does not want to pay for it in advance. The earn-out spreads that risk: if the company performs as predicted, the deferred payment follows.
Based on agreed performance criteria over a specific period, such as revenue, gross profit, or EBITDA over one to three years. You specify the exact formula, the basis, and any ceiling in the purchase agreement.
Because the seller no longer has control after the acquisition, while his deferred payment depends on the results influenced by the buyer. Unclear criteria and disputes regarding the measurement of revenue and costs are the main causes.
Yes. The relationship is governed by reasonableness and fairness (Article 6:248 of the Dutch Civil Code). The buyer may not deliberately frustrate the earn-out. If he prevents the fulfillment of the condition, it may nevertheless be deemed fulfilled pursuant to Article 6:23 of the Dutch Civil Code.
By precisely describing the criteria and the calculation, with examples and clear principles, and by making concrete agreements regarding management during the earn-out period, such as investments, information rights, and decision-making authority.
Not if the full price is paid upon delivery. As soon as a part becomes dependent on results after the acquisition, legal advice is highly recommended, because the determination of the criteria and the duty of care are where things go wrong.