Legal Affairs

Who must provide proof for a return?

If a consumer invokes his right of withdrawal and returns the product, he must be able to prove that he returned it in a timely and correct manner. The consumer therefore bears, in principle, the burden of proof — and the risk...

Published on 14 February 2022 by MKBjuristen.nl
Request a free quote Call 085 25000 44

MKB Juristen drafts custom legal documents

It is best not to cobble together or copy important contracts, terms and conditions, and other legal documents yourself. We help entrepreneurs on a budget with customized legal solutions, clear costs upfront, and practical explanations.

  • Custom contracts, terms and conditions, and legal documents
  • Budget-friendly and clear about the costs upfront
  • Request a free consultation or a no-obligation quote
Free consultation Request a free quote

If a consumer invokes their right of withdrawal and returns the product, they must be able to prove that they returned it in a timely and correct manner. The consumer therefore bears, in principle, the burden of proof — and the risk — of the return shipment, even if the package gets lost in transit.

The right of withdrawal in brief

In principle, a consumer may revoke and return an online purchase within fourteen days. If they return the product on time and undamaged, you, as a webshop, must refund the purchase amount. But what if the package never arrives?

Who has to prove the shipment?

It is up to the consumer to prove that he returned the product in a timely and correct manner. If he claims to have returned the product but nothing arrives, he must prove this — for example, with proof of shipment and track and trace. In principle, you are not required to issue a refund without proof of shipment.

The risk of the return shipment

In principle, the consumer bears the risk of the return: if the package is lost in transit, this is in principle at his expense, provided you have informed him correctly. Therefore, registered or traceable shipping is in his own interest.

What does this mean for your webshop?

Clearly inform consumers how and within what timeframe they must return items, and that proof of shipment is required. Stipulate this in your terms and conditions and on your returns page. This will prevent disputes regarding lost returns.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I have to issue a refund if a return never arrives?

In principle, only if the consumer proves that they returned the item on time and correctly. Without proof of shipment, you are not required to issue a refund.

Who bears the risk of the return shipment?

In principle, the consumer, provided you have informed him correctly. A traceable shipment is in his own interest.

How do I avoid disputes about returns?

Clearly state the return procedure and the required proof of shipment, and stipulate this in your terms and conditions.

Are your return and webshop terms and conditions in order?

Our legal experts incorporate a comprehensive return policy into your general terms and conditions and perform a legal scan of your webshop. Schedule a free consultation.

Please note: an article provides general information, but your legal situation may turn out differently.

A contract, conflict, or legal risk must always be assessed based on the facts, documents, evidentiary position, and interests. Are you in doubt? Have your situation assessed before you act.

Legal question regarding this article?

A blog provides explanation, but your situation often requires a concrete legal choice. MKB Juristen helps entrepreneurs with contracts, terms and conditions, GDPR documents, employment documents, disputes, and customized legal solutions.

Drafting, reviewing, and amending contracts
Legal Assistance Help with conflicts and disputes.
Expertise Specialist legal experts and lawyers.
Fixed rates. Clarity on costs in advance.

Latest articles

September 9, 2026

What is a freelancer hiring check for the client? Explanation and use

What is a freelancer hiring check for the client? Explanation of the role, when you need it, and what to look out for...

September 9, 2026

Having a statute of limitations interruption drafted: costs and process

Having a legal expert draft the interruption of the statute of limitations: what does it cost, how does the process work, and when should you choose custom work over a...

September 9, 2026

Drafting an agreement for hiring and leasing self-employed professionals: this is what should be included

Drafting an agreement for hiring and leasing freelancers? Read about the components that should be included, common mistakes, and when to consult a lawyer.

September 8, 2026

What are the general terms and conditions for companies that sell training and courses? Function and legal status

What are general terms and conditions for companies that sell education and courses? Explanation of the function, when you need it and where...

  • We worked for, among others:
  • MKBjuristen.nl partner
  • MKBjuristen.nl partner
  • MKBjuristen.nl partner
  • MKBjuristen.nl partner
Newsletter for entrepreneurs

Receive practical legal tips in your mailbox

Register now

Enter your email address and receive our newsletter.

No spam. Only legal tips.
By registering, you agree to our privacy statement.
SME Lawyers at the Chamber of Commerce Source: Chamber of Commerce 2019
Free consultation