MKB Juristen drafts custom legal documents
It is best not to cobble together or copy important contracts, terms and conditions, and other legal documents yourself. We help entrepreneurs on a budget with customized legal solutions, clear costs upfront, and practical explanations.
- Custom contracts, terms and conditions, and legal documents
- Budget-friendly and clear about the costs upfront
- Request a free consultation or a no-obligation quote
What is a management agreement for a director-major shareholder? It is the agreement in which the personal holding company of a director-major shareholder agrees to manage or direct another BV, usually the operating company, in exchange for a management fee. The agreement is therefore concluded between two legal entities, the management BV and the operating BV, and not between the director-major shareholder as a natural person and the operating BV. Legally, this is in principle a contract for services (Article 7:400 of the Dutch Civil Code), not an employment contract. This distinction determines the tax treatment, liability, and protection of the director-major shareholder.
The short answer
- Parties: the management BV (personal holding company of the director-major shareholder) and the operating BV over which management is conducted.
- Nature: a contract for services (Art. 7:400 BW), not an employment contract between the director-major shareholder and the operating BV.
- Remuneration: a management fee, generally subject to VAT, unless a VAT group exists.
- Tax-wise: the director-major shareholder must draw a customary salary from the holding company (Art. 12a Income Tax Act 1964).
- Insurance: a director-major shareholder with sufficient control is not insured under employee insurance schemes.
- Risk: if the holding company is a director, the director-major shareholder may be held personally jointly liable under Article 2:11 of the Dutch Civil Code.
What is a management agreement for a director-major shareholder and what is the structure?
The standard SME structure consists of a personal holding company with one or more operating companies underneath it. Through the holding company, the director-major shareholder is a shareholder and often also a director of the operating company. The work performed by the director-major shareholder for the operating company is not provided directly, but via the holding company. To this end, the two companies enter into a management agreement.
The holding company invoices a management fee to the operating company. This fee is the consideration for the management and activities performed by the director-major shareholder on behalf of the holding company. The advantage of this structure is tax flexibility: profits can be retained within the holding company, dividends can be distributed on a planned basis, and the business assets are separated from the operational risks in the operating company.
Assignment or employment contract?
The question of whether an employment contract exists revolves around three characteristics of Article 7:610 of the Dutch Civil Code: work, wages, and a relationship of authority. For a director-major shareholder, authority is the decisive factor. A director who cannot dismiss himself through his voting rights in the general meeting is not subject to authority. In that case, there is no employment relationship, and a contract for services applies.
- Sole shareholder-director. If the director-major shareholder holds the majority of the votes, there is no hierarchical relationship and therefore no employment contract with the operating BV.
- Equal shares. If multiple directors hold a (virtually) equal share, for example one-third each, the same often applies: none of them can be voted out by the others against their will.
- Minority interest. If the director-major shareholder holds a minority interest without decisive control, an employment relationship or a fictitious employment relationship may still arise.
With regard to employee insurance schemes, the Regulation designating a director-major shareholder determines when someone qualifies as a director-major shareholder and is therefore not compulsorily insured for unemployment benefits (WW), disability benefits (WIA), and sickness benefits (ZW). Consequently, a true director-major shareholder does not accrue entitlement through these insurance schemes and usually arranges income protection themselves.
The customary wage scheme
Even if the director-major shareholder performs his work through the holding company, for tax purposes he is not allowed to calculate his own financial poverty without limit. Article 12a of the 1964 Wage Tax Act obliges the director-major shareholder with a substantial interest to draw a customary salary from his BV. That salary is set at the highest of three amounts: the salary from the most comparable employment, the salary of the highest-earning ordinary employee in the enterprise, and a statutory standard amount (set at 56,000 euros in 2024).
The customary salary is paid by the holding company to the director-major shareholder and constitutes salary from employment with their own BV. The management fee that the holding company receives from the operating BV is separate from this: that is revenue of the holding company. Anyone who sets the salary too low runs the risk of a correction by the Tax and Customs Administration.
Directors' liability
A management agreement does not shield the director-major shareholder from liability. Various regulations can run concurrently.
- Internal liability (Art. 2:9 BW). The director is liable to the company for improper performance of duties.
- Bankruptcy (Art. 2:248 BW). In the event of manifestly improper management that is a major cause of the bankruptcy, the director may be liable for the deficit.
- Unlawful act (Art. 6:162 BW). Towards third parties, for example when entering into obligations while it was clear that the BV could not fulfill them.
- Piercing the corporate veil via the holding company (Art. 2:11 BW). If the management BV is a director of the operating BV, then the directors' liability also rests on the director of that holding company, i.e., on the director-major shareholder personally.
That last rule is crucial in SME practice. Many director-major shareholders believe that the interposed holding company shields them, but Article 2:11 of the Dutch Civil Code extends liability to the natural person behind the director-legal entity.
Practical example
Two entrepreneurs jointly establish an operating company, each through their own holding company and each holding fifty percent. Both holding companies are directors of the operating company and enter into a management agreement for a fee of 8,000 euros per month. Because neither can vote the other out of office, there is no hierarchical relationship and therefore no employment relationship with the operating company. Both draw a customary salary from their own holding companies pursuant to Article 12a of the Income Tax Act. When the operating company ran into financial difficulties, the agreement clearly showed which duties and responsibilities lay with each director, which limited disputes regarding liability.
Honest recommendation
For a simple situation involving a single holding company above an operating company and a single director-major shareholder holding full control, a solid model will suffice; a lawyer is not strictly necessary in this case. However, do engage one as soon as there are multiple shareholders or directors, when agreements regarding competition, notice periods, or the distribution of management fees need to be made, or when external investors join. In those cases, the management agreement touches upon the shareholders' agreement, the customary remuneration scheme, and directors' liability simultaneously. An agreement that is flawed on any of these points will almost always cost more in the event of a conflict or bankruptcy than having it drafted carefully.
Read more: drafting a management agreement for a director-major shareholder and having a management agreement for a director-major shareholder drafted. Want to have it arranged immediately? Go to management agreement for director-major shareholder.
Frequently Asked Questions
It is the agreement between the personal holding company of a director-major shareholder and an operating BV, in which the holding company exercises management or leadership over that operating BV in exchange for a management fee. Legally, it is in principle a contract for services (Article 7:400 of the Dutch Civil Code), concluded between two legal entities.
In principle, no. An employment contract requires a relationship of authority (Art. 7:610 BW). A director-major shareholder who cannot dismiss himself through his control is not subject to authority; therefore, there is no employment relationship with the operating BV. However, an employment relationship may arise in the case of a minority interest without a decisive vote.
Article 12a of the 1964 Wage Tax Act obliges a director-major shareholder with a substantial interest to draw a customary salary from his private limited company. This is the higher of the salary from the most comparable employment, the salary of the highest-earning employee, and a statutory standard amount (in 2024, €56,000). The Tax and Customs Administration may correct a salary that is too low.
A director-major shareholder with sufficient control over their own dismissal is not compulsorily insured for unemployment benefits (WW), disability benefits (WIA), and sickness benefits (ZW). This follows from the Regulation on the Designation of Director-Major Shareholders. Such a person does not accrue entitlement through these insurance schemes and usually arranges income and disability protection themselves.
Not entirely. If the management BV is the director of the operating BV, Article 2:11 of the Dutch Civil Code extends the directors' liability to the director of that holding company, and thus to the director-major shareholder personally. In addition, Articles 2:9, 2:248, and 6:162 of the Dutch Civil Code apply. The interposed BV is therefore no guarantee against personal liability.
As a general rule, yes. The holding company provides a service to the operating company and, in principle, charges 21 percent VAT on it. If a VAT group exists between the holding company and the operating company, intercompany transactions remain exempt from VAT. Have this assessed on a case-by-case basis for each structure.
The holding structure offers tax flexibility: profits can remain within the holding company, dividends can be distributed on a scheduled basis, and business assets are separated from operational risks. Furthermore, the director-major shareholder is not bound by the dismissal rights associated with a standard employment contract. On the other hand, the director-major shareholder is responsible for their own income protection.