Labor matters

Broader burden of proof in cases of unlawful employee absence

Since January 1, 2020, the rule applies: no work, still pay — unless the failure to work falls within the employee's sphere of risk. The burden of proof for this has shifted to the employer. If you wish to withhold wages during absence, then...

Published on February 12, 2020 by MKBjuristen.nl
Request a free quote Call 085 25000 44

MKB Juristen drafts custom legal documents

It is best not to cobble together or copy important contracts, terms and conditions, and other legal documents yourself. We help entrepreneurs on a budget with customized legal solutions, clear costs upfront, and practical explanations.

  • Custom contracts, terms and conditions, and legal documents
  • Budget-friendly and clear about the costs upfront
  • Request a free consultation or a no-obligation quote
Free consultation Request a free quote

Since January 1, 2020, the rule applies: no work, still pay — unless the failure to work falls within the employee's sphere of risk. The burden of proof for this has shifted to the employer. If you wish to withhold wages during absence, you must demonstrate that the cause is attributable to the employee.

The reversal since 2020

Under the old law, the principle of 'no work, no pay' applied: in principle, anyone who did not work was not entitled to wages. Since 2020, the basic principle has been reversed to 'no work, but pay, unless' (Article 7:628 of the Dutch Civil Code). The employee retains their wages, unless the failure to work can reasonably be attributed to them.

When are you allowed to withhold wages?

Withholding wages is only permitted if the cause of the absence lies within the employee's sphere of risk, such as unauthorized absence or oversleeping. If the cause lies within your sphere or in a shared risk, the employee retains the right to wages.

The burden of proof lies with you

The most important consequence of the legislative change: as an employer, you must prove that the absence is attributable to the employee. If you cannot do so, you must continue to pay the salary. Carefully document the absence and the reason for it.

Practical tips

Record absences and the communicated reason, apply clear absence rules in your personnel policy, and do not resort to withholding too quickly. If in doubt, do not unilaterally suspend the entire salary — that could backfire.

Frequently Asked Questions

Am I allowed to withhold wages if an employee oversleeps?

Yes, because that falls within his sphere of risk. You must, however, be able to substantiate that the absence is attributable to the employee.

Who must prove that there is no entitlement to wages?

Since 2020, you, the employer. If that proof is not successful, the employee retains his salary.

May I suspend the salary in case of doubt?

Be careful: unilaterally withholding the full salary when in doubt is risky. Have your position assessed before making deductions.

Questions about wages and absenteeism?

Our legal experts advise on continued payment of wages and absenteeism, and incorporate the rules into your employment contract. View our employment lawteam or schedule a free consultation.

Please note: an article provides general information, but your legal situation may turn out differently.

A contract, conflict, or legal risk must always be assessed based on the facts, documents, evidentiary position, and interests. Are you in doubt? Have your situation assessed before you act.

Legal question regarding this article?

A blog provides explanation, but your situation often requires a concrete legal choice. MKB Juristen helps entrepreneurs with contracts, terms and conditions, GDPR documents, employment documents, disputes, and customized legal solutions.

Drafting, reviewing, and amending contracts
Legal Assistance Help with conflicts and disputes.
Expertise Specialist legal experts and lawyers.
Fixed rates. Clarity on costs in advance.

Latest articles

July 25, 2026

IT contracts for SMEs: which ones do you need?

IT contracts for SMEs: SLA, Data Processing Agreement/DPA, SaaS, licensing, maintenance, and development. What each is for and how they relate.

July 24, 2026

Having general terms and conditions drafted for the website: costs and process

Having general terms and conditions for the website drafted by a lawyer: what does it cost, how does the process work, and when should you choose custom-made...

July 24, 2026

Having a non-compete clause drafted: costs and process

Having a non-compete clause drafted by a lawyer: what does it cost, how does the process work, and when to choose a custom draft over a template.

July 24, 2026

Checking contracts: step-by-step plan for SME entrepreneurs

Checking or reviewing a contract before signing: step-by-step plan, red flags, checklist, and when you need a lawyer.

  • We worked for, among others:
  • MKBjuristen.nl partner
  • MKBjuristen.nl partner
  • MKBjuristen.nl partner
  • MKBjuristen.nl partner
Newsletter for entrepreneurs

Receive practical legal tips in your mailbox

Register now

Enter your email address and receive our newsletter.

No spam. Only legal tips.
By registering, you agree to our privacy statement.
SME Lawyers at the Chamber of Commerce Source: Chamber of Commerce 2019
Free consultation