MKB Juristen drafts custom legal documents
It is best not to cobble together or copy important contracts, terms and conditions, and other legal documents yourself. We help entrepreneurs on a budget with customized legal solutions, clear costs upfront, and practical explanations.
- Custom contracts, terms and conditions, and legal documents
- Budget-friendly and clear about the costs upfront
- Request a free consultation or a no-obligation quote
Tax strategies with a Dubai component: holding structure (NL + Dubai), royalty routing, management fee allocation, real estate investment. Some are legitimate (with substance and arm's length), others risky (artificial constructions). Distinction is crucial — anti-abuse rules (ATAD, GAAR, MLI) target artificial structures. Below are the routes and how to remain legitimate.
The short answer
- Legitimate: structures with substance, arm's length, commercial reality.
- Risky: artificial structures solely for tax advantage.
- Anti-abuse: ATAD GAAR, MLI Principal Purpose Test, NL fraus legis.
- Frequently used: holding structure, royalty routing, management fees.
- Requirements: substance, transfer pricing, documentation.
Strategy 1: NL Holding + Dubai operating company
Structure: NL holding company holds shares in UAE operating company. Dubai operating company performs operational activity. Benefits:
- Dutch participation exemption: dividend from Dubai operating company tax-free in the Netherlands.
- UAE-Corporate Tax 9% (or 0% via QFZP) on profit.
- Effective tax: virtually only UAE rate.
Conditions for legitimacy:
- Actual operational activity Dubai operating company.
- Substance UAE: office, people, board meetings.
- NL-UAE Tax Treaty applies.
- No artificial intermediate step.
Strategy 2: IP holder in UAE
Structure: Intellectual property (trademarks, patents, software) held by the Dubai company. Other group companies pay royalties for use.
Works:
- IP actually developed or transferred to Dubai company.
- Royalty's arm's length (market rate).
- UAE IP owner has a real role (R&D, management).
- QFZP-eligible for IP revenue.
Risks:
- Artificial IP transfer without commercial reason: GAAR hit.
- Royalties above market rate: transfer pricing adjustment.
- No genuine UAE IP management: substance violation.
Strategy 3: Management fee allocation
Dutch operating company pays management fee to Dubai company for management services. Reduces Dutch profit, increases Dubai profit.
Works:
- Actual services provided by a Dubai company.
- Management fees arm's length.
- UAE personnel with a management role.
Risks:
- No real services provided: artificial.
- Excessive fee: TP correction.
- The Dutch operating company has its own local management: a dual role.
Strategy 4: Real estate investment Dubai
Dubai real estate via personal purchase or through a UAE company. Benefits:
- No transfer tax (only 4% DLD fee).
- No capital gains tax on sale.
- No wealth tax.
- Investor visa for over €190,000.
For Dutch residents:
- Box 3 return required.
- Dubai real estate falls under Dutch assets.
- Tax treaty prevents double taxation.
Anti-abuse rules
ATAD GAAR (General Anti-Abuse Rule)
EU Directive: arrangements without commercial reality can be disregarded. Test: main objective of tax benefit? If so: structure can be broken.
MLI PPT (Principal Purpose Test)
The NL-UAE Tax Treaty contains MLI clauses. PPT tests: was the tax benefit a principal purpose or one of the principal purposes? If so: treaty benefits denied.
NL fraus legis
Dutch anti-abuse doctrine: in cases of avoidance with the sole intention of tax evasion, the judge may disregard the structure.
Legitimate versus risky — checklist
Legitimate signals
- Substance in UAE: office, people, activity.
- Commercial reason other than tax: market access, customers.
- Arm's length transactions.
- Documentation and TP reports.
- Actual operational activity.
Risk signals
- No substance: mailbox company.
- No other reason than tax.
- Intercompany prices that are too high or too low.
- Recent structural change prior to tax event.
- No demonstrable activity.
Floor's strategy
Floor chooses: NL holding + UAE operating company (free zone, QFZP). Not:
- Artificial royalty route (no IP transfer).
- Management fee without real services.
- Real estate in the form of a private limited company without a commercial reason.
Yes: move actual operational activity to Dubai, build substance, TP documentation. Investment 30k euros/year substance + 10k advice. For 250k euros profit: marginally advantageous with a legitimate structure.
Honest recommendation
A tax strategy with a Dubai component is not a “trick”. For a legitimate structure: substance, arm's length, and commercial reality. Anti-abuse rules (ATAD, MLI, fraus legis) target artificial structures. Invest in an international tax specialist for strategy design (€10,000–€50,000); do not skimp on advice. Better a smaller, legitimate structure than a large, risky one. In case of doubt: seek prior advice from the Tax and Customs Administration (ATR procedure).
For other topics: substance requirements, transfer pricing and risks in Dubai.
Frequently Asked Questions
Dutch holding company + Dubai operating company (participation exemption + UAE rate), IP holder Dubai with arm's length royalties, management fee for genuine services, real estate investment. Provided there is substance, commercial reality, and arm's length.
General Anti-Abuse Rule under ATAD: arrangements without commercial reality can be disregarded by the Tax Authorities. Test: primary purpose of tax benefit without other business reason? If so: the structure can be broken.
Principal Purpose Test in MLI (Multilateral Instrument, in tax treaties since 2019): was the tax benefit principal purpose? If so: treaty benefits denied. The NL-UAE tax treaty contains a PPT.
Dutch anti-abuse doctrine: in cases of avoidance with the sole intention of tax avoidance without commercial reality, the judge may disregard the structure and tax it as if the structure did not exist.
IP actually transferred to Dubai company, royalties at arm's length (market rate), UAE IP owner has a genuine role (R&D management), commercial reason for transfer. No artificial intermediate step solely for tax gain.
Actual services provided by Dubai company, UAE staff with management roles, fee arm's length, no dual function with Dutch operating company. No “paper” fee without service.
Yes, prior certainty from the Tax and Customs Administration via an Advance Tax Ruling. For complex or high-risk structures: the ATR requires prior tax certainty. Costs 5-15k euros, turnaround time 6-12 months. Provides legal certainty for strategy.
